Writings

Personal Essay

People are terrible mirrors.

— B.W. Alan

People are terrible mirrors. The tragedy is, we keep asking them who we are. — I remember standing in a kitchen I didn’t belong in anymore, asking someone who had already stopped seeing me to tell me what they saw. I don’t know what I expected. Some truth they’d been holding back. Some accurate account of who I was — finally spoken, finally delivered, as if clarity was something another person could hand you if only they cared enough to try. What I got instead was their disappointment in a shape that looked like mine. Their unfinished grief wearing my face. Their fear of what I represented to them, dressed up as an assessment of my character. I thanked them. I left. And then I went looking for the next mirror. — This is what we do with the people we love, the people we leave, the people we barely know but somehow give enormous power to. We hand them a question that isn’t theirs to answer. Who am I? We ask it in ten thousand ways — through the way we wait for someone to notice us, through the way we collapse when they don’t, through the way we rehearse old conversations long after they’ve ended, trying to find the version where we came out looking the way we needed to. We outsource our identity like it’s a task we can delegate. And then we are shocked — genuinely, repeatedly shocked — when what comes back is wrong. Here’s what nobody tells you about other people as mirrors: every single one of them is cracked. Not because they’re broken or bad or mean, though sometimes they are those things too. But because every human being looks at you through the accumulated sediment of their own history. Their mother who never said I’m proud of you. The friend who left. The version of themselves they abandoned. The love they didn’t survive. All of it — every last wound and wonder — sits between them and you like a pane of old glass, warping the image before it ever arrives. When someone tells you that you’re too much, they are not describing you. They are describing the size of their own container. When someone tells you that you’re not enough, they are not measuring you. They are measuring the distance between you and the person they needed you to be. When someone tells you who you are in anger, in grief, in the middle of their own unraveling — they are writing their autobiography, not yours. None of this makes the words land any softer. That’s the cruelty of borrowed mirrors. Even when you know they’re wrong, you can still feel them. Even when you know it’s projection, you can still absorb it. Even when you know better — you know better — you can stand in someone else’s perception of you and feel yourself slowly becoming it. Because you are looking for something real. And even a distorted image is still an image. — So let me ask you something. Think about the narratives you carry about yourself — the deep ones, the ones so old you’ve forgotten they came from somewhere. I’m too sensitive. I’m too much. I’m not the kind of person people stay for. I ask for too much. I peaked early. I give too little. Now ask yourself: whose voice said that first? Whose disappointment became your definition? Whose inability to love you well became the story you tell about what you deserve? Because that’s what happens when we make other people our mirrors for too long. We stop questioning the reflection. We start maintaining it. We start organizing our entire lives around proving it right or wrong, and either way — they’re still in the frame. The tragedy isn’t that people are bad at this. The tragedy is that we keep returning anyway. We change the mirror. We find a newer one, a cleaner one, someone who hasn’t seen us fail yet, someone who still believes the version we’re trying to be. And we hand them the same question, hoping this time the answer will finally feel true. Tell me who I am. Please. This time, get it right. — I don’t know when I stopped asking. It wasn’t a single moment. It was more like erosion — the slow realization that no one else had ever had the information required to answer accurately. That the most honest account anyone had given me was still filtered through a thousand things that had nothing to do with me. That the people who loved me most still couldn’t see me clearly, not because they didn’t try, but because clarity isn’t something one person can achieve for another. You are not a reflection. You exist whether or not anyone is looking. You have a texture, a weight, a particular way of moving through this world that does not depend on being witnessed to be real. The self doesn’t require an audience to exist. It requires tending. Not performance. Tending. There’s a difference between asking someone how do I seem to you — curious, open, able to take the answer as information rather than verdict — and asking someone tell me who I am, which is a surrender of the question to the wrong authority. You are the authority. You are the only one who has been there for all of it — every version, every quiet season, every thing you did when no one was watching, every moment you chose something true over something convenient. No mirror holds that. No person carries that archive. Only you. The work isn’t finding a better mirror. The work is learning to look somewhere else entirely. — B.W. Alan