Writings

Personal Essay

Some conversations don’t end.

— B.W. Alan

Some conversations don’t end. They just run out of people willing to keep having them. — I want to name something you’ve probably never named. The argument you’re still having in the shower. The explanation you’ve been composing in your head for three years. The apology that has four different versions by now. The response you finally thought of at 2am, two weeks after the conversation that needed it. The person you’re talking to — where are they? They might be gone. Estranged. Dead. They might have simply moved on in the way people move on, become someone who no longer occupies space in your daily life. They stopped having this conversation with you, maybe years ago. You never did. — This is what happens to conversations that don’t get properly closed. They continue — not as events you can point to, but as interior weather. You are still having them. Every time you defend the choice you made. Every time you explain yourself to someone who isn’t there. Every time you hear what they would say and compose your answer. The difference is, now you’re playing both parts. — It happens in ways you’ve probably never stopped to name. You’re describing something that happened at work, and midway through the telling you realize you’re shaping it for an audience that isn’t there — making the same emphases, saving the same detail for the same moment, because that’s how you’d have told it to them. You rehearse a version of events for someone who will never hear it. You make a decision — something small, or something enormous — and filter it through what they’d think. Not what you think. What they would think. And you adjust accordingly. The voice of someone who stopped having opinions about your life years ago is still being consulted on it. You avoid a restaurant. You don’t call someone you have every reason to call. And only later, if at all, do you trace it back: that was for them. That was the conversation you’re still having. You encounter something — a piece of news, a beautiful sentence, something unfair — and your first impulse is to tell them. And in the half-second before you remember that you can’t, you’ve already composed the first line. This is what the interior conversation actually looks like. Not dramatic. Not visible. Just the quiet ongoing narration of a life to an audience that has been gone for years. — Think about who you’ve been in conversation with this week. Not the people you spoke to out loud. The other ones. The parent who has been dead for ten years but whose voice still weighs in on decisions. The friend who stopped calling after the falling out, who you still argue with when you encounter something they would have had an opinion about. The person who hurt you, to whom you’ve been composing the perfect response for longer than the relationship actually lasted. You are not done with these conversations. And here is the thing worth sitting with: the version of them you’re talking to is almost entirely constructed by you. The response you imagine them giving? You wrote it. The argument you’re preparing for? You authored both sides. The apology you’re rehearsing? You’ve already decided whether they’d accept it. The conversation continued. But at some point, you became its only author. — Some conversations end when both people leave the room. But some stay open — not because you failed at moving on, but because the ending wasn’t adequate to the weight of what needed to be said. Because someone left before the conversation was finished. Because the things left unspoken kept requiring air, and the air kept going after they did. You cannot close it alone. That much is true. But you can stop waiting for the closure to require two people. You can say what you needed to say — into the quiet, in writing, in whatever form the conversation finally wants to take — and let that be the ending that the conversation, and you, deserved. — Some conversations don’t end. But at some point, they become entirely yours to finish. — B.W. Alan