Writings
Personal Essay
Sometimes the longest relationship you’ll ever have
— B.W. Alan
Sometimes the longest relationship you’ll ever have
is with a version of someone that no longer exists.
—
Let me describe the relationship.
You know exactly what they would say. You know how they’d react to the thing that just happened — the work decision, the difficult conversation, the news you don’t know what to do with. You know their voice, their phrasing, the particular way they’d hold their coffee while they thought about it.
You know them cold.
Except they haven’t changed in fifteen years.
The person you know so well is fixed at a specific configuration — a particular age, a particular set of beliefs, a version of themselves that existed during the years when you knew them most closely. What they’ve become since then, you can only guess at.
But the relationship continues. Ongoing. Interior. Sometimes daily.
—
What makes this strange is that the frozen version isn’t passive. Memory would be passive. Nostalgia would be passive.
But what you actually have is more active than that. The frozen version sits in the room when you’re making decisions. You think: she would have said something cutting about that, so you adjust. You succeed at something and your first instinct is to tell him — not the person he’s become, but the one who understood why this particular thing mattered. You do something you’re not proud of and hear, clearly, what they would have thought.
The frozen version still has opinions. Still has weight in the room.
The person who shaped you during the years you knew them most closely doesn’t stop shaping you simply because they’ve moved on. They installed something. And the installation keeps running.
—
Here’s what makes it stranger still.
You have no idea whether the frozen version resembles who they actually became.
The real person — the one out there somewhere, having years you know nothing about — may have changed in every direction. May have softened in the places that used to be hard. May have become someone the frozen version wouldn’t recognize. May have arrived at understandings that would have changed everything between you.
But you can’t update the installation. You only have the version you have.
—
And here is the part that stays strange the longer you sit with it.
The version you carry does not exist anywhere in the world except inside you.
The real person has kept becoming. Has had years you know nothing about — losses, decisions, changes, the slow revision that happens to everyone who keeps living. The person they are now has outgrown the version you hold. May have arrived at things that would have changed everything between you. May have become someone you would have loved differently, or not at all, or more.
You will never know. You only have the one you’ve been keeping.
Which means the most intimate knowledge you have of them exists nowhere else on earth. You are, in the most literal sense, the sole custodian of a version the world has long since moved past. What you know of them — the specific configuration of them at a specific moment in time — is yours alone to carry. Not because they gave it to you. Because you kept it after they stopped.
—
There is a specific loneliness in being the last one still in this relationship.
The person has moved on — is someone else now, in their ordinary life, having accumulated years you know nothing about. They may not think of you often. The relationship you’re maintaining with them, they are not maintaining with you. They’ve become a stranger. You’ve remained their intimate.
And there is grief in that asymmetry that almost never gets named.
—
I don’t think you need to end these relationships.
The length of the attachment says something real about the quality of what existed — you don’t carry someone this long, this actively, unless something between you mattered in a way that earned it.
But you might need to know what you’re actually carrying.
Not the person. Not who they’ve become, not who they are now, somewhere out there accumulating a life you’ll never see.
A version. Fixed at the height of what you knew together, held there by your fidelity to what they meant to you. Still in the room. Still shaping choices. Still receiving news you never deliver.
Existing, now, only in you.
That’s not a small thing to be the keeper of. It’s just important to know that’s what you are.
— B.W. Alan