Writings

Personal Essay

You don’t miss who they are.

— B.W. Alan

You don’t miss who they are. You miss who they were before they taught you who they could be. — There’s a specific moment. You may not have clocked it at the time. It didn’t announce itself. It didn’t arrive with the weight it deserved, the way the turning points in stories always seem to in retrospect — large and lit, unmistakable. It arrived quietly. Just a moment when something shifted in you, a small recalibration, a notch downward in something you’d been holding up without knowing it. The moment you saw clearly. The moment you understood, in some interior and unspoken way, who they actually were. — We talk about missing people like it’s a simple thing. Like what we miss is the person — the three-dimensional, present-tense, actually-existing human being who is still alive somewhere, still moving through the world, still having mornings and meals and conversations we aren’t part of. But most of the time, we don’t miss that. We miss the version we had before. Before the thing that taught us who they could be. — People reveal themselves slowly, and then all at once. For a long time — a season, years, sometimes a whole chapter of your life — you know someone by the best of them. By the way they were when they were trying, or when they were happy, or when nothing had gone wrong yet, or when the circumstances that would later reveal something essential hadn’t arrived. And you build yourself a person from those observations. You build something coherent, something you trust, something you’ve let in close enough to matter. And then something happens. A pressure arrives. A conflict emerges. A moment comes when they are tested and you see what the test produces — and what it produces is something that doesn’t match the person you built. Not dramatically, maybe. Not in a way anyone else would notice. Just: something that sits wrong. Something that reveals a shape underneath the one you’d been loving. And you can’t unsee it. — This is not heartbreak, though it can feel like heartbreak. Heartbreak is the loss of someone. This is something else: the loss of who you thought they were. The collapse of a specific construction. The end of a version of them that may never have fully existed outside of your belief in it. What you mourn is not them. What you mourn is your understanding of them. What you mourn is the person you were when you still believed the version you’d built. — The cruelest part of disillusionment is that they often don’t know it happened. They are living their life, being who they are, uncomplicated by the revelation that leveled something in you. They didn’t feel the shift. They can’t see what you saw, because you saw it from a particular angle they don’t have access to — the angle of someone who loved the version that was there before, and knows exactly what has been replaced. You are carrying a grief they’re not even aware you’re in. — And then you miss them. Not as they are. Not as they revealed themselves to be. Not the whole person, capable of the thing they were capable of. You miss the version you had before you knew. You miss the morning when everything was still intact. The conversation before the one that changed things. The feeling of not yet knowing what you know. The specific and now-vanished safety of not having been taught. This is the deepest loss in disillusionment: not the person, but the innocence. Not who they are, but who you were before they showed you who they could be. — I don’t know what to do with that except name it. Because I think we spend a lot of time and energy trying to return to the version. Trying to get the person back to who they were before. Trying to find the thing we trusted, to relocate it somewhere in who they’ve shown us they are. And sometimes it’s there. Sometimes the revelation is survivable and the relationship continues and something new and honest is built from what remains. But sometimes what you saw was the truth. And you have to decide what to do with a truth you can’t give back. You don’t have to stop loving them. You don’t have to hate what you learned. You don’t have to pretend the version you loved wasn’t real, because it was. But you do have to let yourself know the difference between the person who was and the person who is — and grieve the gap, if there is one, without expecting them to fill it back up. Some things, once taught, can’t be untaught. The loss isn’t the knowing. The loss is the before. — B.W. Alan